Los Angeles Times
March 10, 1992, Tuesday, Home Edition
U.S. GAVE
DATA TO IRAQ 3 MONTHS BEFORE INVASION;
PERSIAN GULF: DOCUMENTS SHOW INTELLIGENCE SHARING WITH BAGHDAD LASTED LONGER THAN
PREVIOUSLY INDICATED.
BYLINE: By MURRAY WAAS and DOUGLAS FRANTZ, SPECIAL TO THE TIMES; Waas is a special correspondent
and Frantz is a Times staff writer.
SECTION: Part A; Page 1; Column 2; National Desk
LENGTH: 942 words
DATELINE: WASHINGTON
The Bush Administration shared
intelligence information with the regime of Saddam Hussein until at least May, 1990, three months before Iraq's invasion
of Kuwait, according to formerly classified documents.The intelligence cooperation continued far longer than
previously indicated and occurred during a time when Hussein was taking an increasingly belligerent posture in the Persian
Gulf region.
The Bush Administration justified continuing to provide Iraq with information on Iranian
military activities and other intelligence data as a means of retaining access to elements of the government in Baghdad, according
to the documents.
Last fall, a Senate Intelligence Committee report indicated that the panel believed
the intelligence sharing ended in 1988 with a cease-fire in the Iran-Iraq war. The committee had received a number of secret
briefings by Administration officials on policy toward Iraq.
A committee spokesman declined to comment on the apparent
discrepancy Monday, saying only: "We are looking at all the facts."Iraq began to receive intelligence
on Iranian troop movements and other critical issues during the Ronald Reagan Administration as part of the "tilt"
toward Iraq during the eight-year war.
Some intelligence experts have speculated that the information
later helped Iraq learn how to shelter its weapons from U.S. surveillance during Operation Desert Storm, since the Iraqis
knew the types of intelligence available to U.S. agencies.
While the committee report indicated that the
panel believed the cooperation had ended with the Iran-Iraq war, the previously classified State Department document dated
May 16, 1990, says that the sharing only slowed down after the August, 1988, cease-fire.
That report,
addressed to White House National Security Adviser Brent Scowcroft, was prepared to present various options on Iraqi policy
for consideration at a May 24, 1990, meeting of the White House National Security Council's deputies committee. It set
out reasons for continuing the cooperation and for stopping it.
"Intelligence exchanges have waned
since the Gulf War cease-fire," said the report. "PRO: They still provide Iraq with limited information on Iranian
military activity that would be missed. CON: Ending this contact would close off our very limited access to this important
segment of the Iraqi establishment."
The State Department paper indicated that officials at the high-level
interagency meeting were going to consider whether to continue the intelligence sharing. The chairman of the deputies committee
was Robert M. Gates, now CIA director, who then was President Bush's deputy national security adviser.
Mark
Mansfield, a spokesman at the CIA, declined to comment on the documents. "We don't comment on the nature and extent
of intelligence arrangements with any countries," he said.
Attempts to obtain comment from the White
House were unsuccessful.
The State Department paper and related documents from the NSC were made public
Monday by Rep. Henry B. Gonzalez (D-Tex.), chairman of the House Banking, Finance and Urban Affairs Committee, during a statement
on the floor of the House.
The committee is one of a number of congressional committees examining the
covert policies by the Reagan and Bush administrations to assist Hussein from the early 1980s until almost the eve of his
invasion of Kuwait on Aug. 2, 1990. The committees also are examining whether the Administration provided accurate information
to Congress on the Iraqi assistance.
"The revelation that intelligence sharing with Iraq continued
well into 1990 . . . raises new questions about the Administration's reporting to the Senate and House Intelligence committees,"
said Gonzalez. "Based on the fact that the Senate committee report on the Gates nomination contains a misleading date
for the end of the intelligence-sharing arrangement, I wonder if they were properly informed."
In
1984, President Reagan signed a National Security Decision Directive authorizing the CIA to share limited intelligence with
Iraq, according to the report issued last fall by the Senate Intelligence Committee. Two congressional sources said the committee
was told that the first intelligence was shared with Baghdad in December, 1984.
However, the New York
Times reported in January that the Reagan Administration had actually begun providing intelligence to Iraq in the spring of
1982. The account quoted a former CIA official as identifying Gates as the CIA officer in charge of preparing the intelligence
information for Iraq.
During his confirmation hearings last fall, Gates testified that intelligence data
was passed to Baghdad to prevent Iraq from losing the war with Iran. Gates said that the intelligence sharing was carried
out "to enhance their (Iraq's) ability to pursue the war."
At his hearings, Gates did not
discuss a date when the cooperation ended. But during the hearings, the Senate Intelligence Committee released the report
on Iraqi intelligence sharing, which indicated that it had ended in 1988. "Intelligence sharing continued on a sporadic
basis until 1988 when the war between Iraq and Iran ended," said the report.
During confirmation
hearings for Gates, Sen. Bill Bradley (D-N.J.) raised questions about whether the cooperation with Iraq amounted to a "covert
action" that the President was required by law to report to Congress.
A 1975 law prohibits the use
of CIA funds for covert activities "unless and until the President finds that each operation . . . is important to the
national security of the U.S. and reports in a timely fashion" to the House and Senate Intelligence committees.
PERSON: SADDAM HUSSEIN (92%); SADDAM HUSSEIN (92%); ROBERT M GATES (81%); ROBERT
M GATES (81%); GEORGE W BUSH (51%); CHARLES A GONZALEZ (50%); CHARLES A GONZALEZ (50%);
ORGANIZATION: WHITE HOUSE NATIONAL SECURITY COUNCIL (60%); SENATE INTELLIGENCE COMMITTEE (60%); BUSH
ADMINISTRATION (60%);
COUNTRY: IRAQ (96%); UNITED STATES (95%); GULF
STATES (94%); IRAN (94%); KUWAIT (92%);
STATE: INDIAN OCEAN (90%);
CITY: BAGHDAD, IRAQ (92%);
COMPANY: RONALD REAGAN
ADMINISTRATION (83%); STATE DEPARTMENT FEDERAL CREDIT UNION INC (60%); WHITE HOUSE NATIONAL
SECURITY COUNCIL (60%); SENATE INTELLIGENCE COMMITTEE (60%); BUSH ADMINISTRATION (60%);
GEOGRAPHIC: IRAQ (96%); UNITED STATES (95%); GULF STATES (94%); IRAN (94%); KUWAIT (92%); INDIAN
OCEAN (90%); BAGHDAD, IRAQ (92%);
SUBJECT: UNITED STATES -- FOREIGN
RELATIONS -- IRAQ; INTELLIGENCE SERVICES; BUSH, GEORGE; GATES, ROBERT M MILITARY OPERATIONS (90%); INTELLIGENCE
SERVICES (90%); WAR & CONFLICT (90%); US FEDERAL GOVERNMENT (90%); NATIONAL SECURITY (89%); STATE
DEPARTMENTS & FOREIGN SERVICES (89%); DESERT STORM (89%); MILITARY SURVEILLANCE (78%); TALKS
& MEETINGS (75%); LEGISLATIVE BODIES (75%); INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS (74%); US DEMOCRATIC
PARTY (70%); US PRESIDENTS (68%);
LANGUAGE: ENGLISH
Copyright 1992 The
Times Mirror Company; Los Angeles Times All Rights Reserved