Los Angeles Times
September 12, 1992, Saturday, Home Edition
KUWAIT, SAUDIS SUPPLIED IRAQ WITH U.S. ARMS
BYLINE: By MURRAY WAAS and DOUGLAS FRANTZ, SPECIAL TO THE TIMES
SECTION:
Part A; Page 1; Column 6; National Desk
LENGTH: 1155 words
DATELINE:
WASHINGTON
The Kuwaiti and Saudi Arabian monarchies shipped U.S. missiles and bombs to the Iraqi regime of Saddam
Hussein during the Iran-Iraq war without American approval, according to a classified report prepared by congressional investigators.Kuwait, which was invaded by Iraq two years ago, provided the Iraqis with an undisclosed number of TOW anti-tank
missiles and the Saudis sent Baghdad as many as 1,500 bombs, according to intelligence reports cited in the report by the
General Accounting Office, an investigative arm of Congress.
Other U.S. arms may have been transferred
to Iraq by Persian Gulf states during the eight-year war, which ended in August, 1988, but the GAO investigation was stymied
by the refusal of the Bush Administration to press for information from U.S. allies in the region, according to a copy of
the GAO report obtained Friday by The Times.
The GAO report confirms an earlier story in The Times about
the Saudi transfer and suggests that Saudi authorities may have misled U.S. officials about the number of bombs provided to
Iraq. It also raises questions about the accuracy of the required notification the Ronald Reagan Administration later provided
to Congress on the Saudi transfer.
The report sheds more light on the covert efforts of U.S. allies to help Iraq during
this pivotal period, when fears were mounting that Iran was on the brink of victory. The Reagan Administration, though secretly
tilting toward the Hussein regime to bolster its military position, was having great difficulty keeping track of what other
nations were doing, even with U.S.-supplied weaponry.The Bush Administration has admitted there were some
abuses but has characterized them as relatively minor and inadvertent. However, critics have suggested U.S. officials were
deliberately looking the other way while illegal shipments occurred to avoid having to notify Congress and then justify the
transfers.
Although the State Department protested the Kuwaiti shipment, the Reagan Administration made
no effort to recover either the sophisticated anti-tank missiles or the bombs provided by the Saudis.
The
GAO report provides new details and insights on the unauthorized arms shipments but does not answer the fundamental question
about how they occurred.
By directly questioning the veracity of a key American ally, the report could
complicate the plans announced Friday by President Bush to sell sophisticated new F-15 jet fighters to the Saudis.
The
GAO investigation was requested by Rep. Lee H. Hamilton (D-Ind.), chairman of a House Foreign Affairs subcommittee, after
reports that Mideast countries may have served as transfer points for U.S. arms bound for Iraq during its war with Iran. The
report was completed last March but has remained classified "secret" at the insistence of the Bush Administration.
A State Department spokesman had no comment on the GAO report. The department said earlier that the Saudi transfer
of the arms was inadvertent and that Congress was properly notified. Attempts to reach Saudi and Kuwaiti officials were unsuccessful.
The Times reported in February that the Reagan Administration carried out covert policies to arm Iraq during
the Iran-Iraq war by allowing Mideast allies such as Saudi Arabia and Kuwait to transfer U.S. arms to Iraq with prior approval.
The tilt continued after the war ended as the Bush Administration provided economic aid and licensed the sale
of sensitive technology to Baghdad.
The involvement of U.S. officials in allowing the arms transfers would
be a potential violation of the federal Arms Export Control Act, which forbids countries that receive U.S. arms from transferring
them to other nations without the written permission of the United States. The law also requires that Congress be notified
of any such transfers, whether or not they are by authorized the U.S. government.
The GAO report confirmed
that Saudi Arabia and Kuwait had transferred U.S. arms to Iraq, but investigators did not find evidence that U.S. officials
authorized the transfers. An investigator said the role of U.S. officials had not been a focus of the probe.
The
report indicated that the Reagan Administration might have misled Congress about the magnitude of Saudi arms transfers to
Iraq.
The Times reported in April that the Saudis had transferred an undisclosed number of U.S. one-ton
MK-84 bombs to the Iraqis along with a shipment of British jet fighters in 1986.
"In 1986, (the State
Department) received reports that Saudi Arabia had transferred U.S. munitions to Iraq," said the GAO report. "In
response to (the State Department's) inquiry, the Saudi government said that 300 MK-84 2,000-pound bombs were inadvertently
mixed in with a shipment of non-U.S.-origin munitions sent to Iraq in February, 1986."
Congress,
however, was not notified that the Saudis had transferred any bombs, Lawmakers were only told that the shipment involved "a
small quantity of unsophisticated arms," the report said.
The GAO also concluded that the actual
shipment was apparently much larger than the Saudi government admitted. "An intelligence report . . . indicates that
1,500 rather than 300 MK-84 bombs were transferred," the GAO said. "Furthermore, the intelligence indicates that
an unknown quantity of (smaller) MK-82 bombs was also transferred."
Investigators were unable to
determine how many TOW missiles were provided to Iraq by Kuwait. But the report said that after receiving reports of the transfer
in 1984, the State Department delivered a protest to the Kuwaiti government.
The GAO attempted to investigate
evidence that 4,000 fuses for mortar bombs manufactured by Eastman Kodak Co. in Rochester, N.Y., were transferred to Iraq
by the United Arab Emirates in the fall of 1989. But the GAO said the U.S. Embassy in that country refused to allow investigators
to travel there to investigate the allegations because of "political sensitivities."
The GAO
report also found that a number of other nations transferred U.S. arms to Iraq without authorization from Washington. South
Korea provided spare parts for 105-millimeter howitzers, Greece "probably transferred 400,000 rounds of U.S.-origin ammunition
to Iraq in 1986" and Italy in 1985 sold "conversion kits to Iraq for Hughes helicopters that Iraq had purchased
from the U.S. with assurance of non-military use."
But the GAO also found that proposals by Jordan,
Egypt, Oman and Greece to send U.S. weapons to Iraq were turned down by the State Department.
A separate
classified State Department cable supports the possibility that additional U.S. arms were shipped to Iraq. According to the
cable, an official with a Brazilian arms manufacturer told State Department officials in July, 1985, that his employees had
unloaded sophisticated U.S. military equipment, including TOW missiles, at an airport in Iraq.
Waas is a special correspondent, and Frantz is a Times staff writer.
PERSON: SADDAM
HUSSEIN (92%); SADDAM HUSSEIN (92%); GEORGE W BUSH (51%);
ORGANIZATION:
GENERAL ACCOUNTING OFFICE (90%); GENERAL ACCOUNTING OFFICE (57%);
COUNTRY:
UNITED STATES (99%); SAUDI ARABIA (98%); IRAQ (96%); IRAN (94%); KUWAIT (94%); GULF
STATES (79%); MIDDLE EAST (79%);
STATE: INDIAN OCEAN (57%);
CITY: BAGHDAD, IRAQ (90%);
COMPANY: RONALD REAGAN
ADMINISTRATION (73%); STATE DEPARTMENT FEDERAL CREDIT UNION INC (65%); GENERAL ACCOUNTING
OFFICE (90%); GENERAL ACCOUNTING OFFICE (57%);
GEOGRAPHIC: UNITED
STATES (99%); SAUDI ARABIA (98%); IRAQ (96%); IRAN (94%); KUWAIT (94%); GULF
STATES (79%); MIDDLE EAST (79%); INDIAN OCEAN (57%); BAGHDAD, IRAQ (90%);
SUBJECT: IRAQ -- ARMS SALES -- KUWAIT; IRAQ -- -- ARMS SALES -- SAUDI ARABIA; UNITED STATES -- ARMS
SALES -- IRAQ; INVESTIGATIONS ARMS TRADE (90%); INVESTIGATIONS (90%); MILITARY WEAPONS (90%); US
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT (90%); US DEMOCRATIC PARTY (78%); STATE DEPARTMENTS & FOREIGN SERVICES (74%); INTELLIGENCE
SERVICES (72%); PUBLIC FINANCE (71%); FIGHTERS & BOMBERS (69%);
LANGUAGE:
ENGLISH
Copyright 1992 The Times Mirror Company; Los Angeles Times
All Rights Reserved